phrykt

What is insider trading

Updated Nov 11, 2026 · 5 min read · By the Phrykt team, how we write and check guides

Insider trading means two different things. Legal insider trading is when officers, directors or 10% owners trade their own company's stock and report it on Form 4 within two business days. Illegal insider trading is buying or selling a security while knowing material non-public information, in breach of a duty of trust.

One is legal, common and public. The other is a crime. News reports often mix them up, so it helps to keep them apart.

Insider trading is legal when an insider keeps to the rules and reports the trade. Executives and directors often own shares in the company they work for. They receive stock as part of their pay, and some buy more with their own money. When they buy or sell those shares, that is insider trading in the plain sense of the words: an insider is trading.

The report is a Form 4, filed with the Securities and Exchange Commission within two business days of the trade. Anyone can read it. The trades listed on our insider trades page are all of this legal, reported kind.

Who counts as a company insider?

For reporting, the law uses a fixed list. Section 16 of the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 covers three groups:

  • Officers. The top executives, such as the chief executive, the chief financial officer, and others who set policy for the company.
  • Directors. The members of the company's board.
  • 10% owners. Any person or entity that owns more than 10% of a class of the company's stock.

These people file a Form 3 when they become insiders and a Form 4 when their holdings change. The guide to Form 3, Form 4 and Form 5 explains each one.

What makes insider trading illegal?

Illegal insider trading is buying or selling a security while knowing material non-public information about it, in breach of a duty of trust.

  • Material means a reasonable investor would consider the information important. Examples are unannounced earnings, a merger that is being negotiated, or the result of a major drug trial.
  • Non-public means the information has not been released to the market in general.

The main legal basis is Section 10(b) of the Exchange Act and the Commission's Rule 10b-5, which ban fraud in connection with buying or selling securities. Courts have applied them to insider trading for decades.

The illegal kind is not limited to Section 16 insiders. It can apply to:

  • an ordinary employee who learns of a deal before it is announced,
  • an outside lawyer, banker or accountant working for the company,
  • a person who passes a tip to a friend, and the friend who trades on it,
  • someone who takes confidential information from their employer and trades on it.

Members of Congress and their staff are covered too. The STOCK Act made that explicit in 2012.

What is the short-swing profit rule?

Section 16(b) adds a simple, mechanical rule for officers, directors and 10% owners. If one of them buys and then sells the company's stock within six months, or sells and then buys within six months, any profit must be paid back to the company.

It does not matter why they traded or what they knew. No proof of wrongdoing is needed. The company can claim the money, and if it does not, a shareholder can sue on its behalf. The rule is meant to remove the reward for quick in-and-out trading by people close to the company.

What are blackout periods and trading windows?

Most listed companies have their own insider trading policy on top of the law. Two common tools are:

  • Blackout periods. Times when insiders may not trade at all. A typical one runs from near the end of a quarter until shortly after the results are published.
  • Trading windows. The open periods between blackouts, when trading is allowed, often only after approval by the company's legal team.

These are company policies, not legal deadlines, and they differ from one company to the next. They explain why insider trades tend to bunch up in the weeks after earnings reports.

Some insiders also use a pre-set schedule, called a Rule 10b5-1 plan, so that trades can go ahead at times when they would otherwise be barred.

What are the penalties for illegal insider trading?

Illegal insider trading can lead to a civil case by the regulator and criminal charges, with penalties that include giving up the profit, fines and prison. The Securities and Exchange Commission can bring a civil case. It can ask a court to make the person give up the profit, pay a penalty of up to three times the profit made or the loss prevented, and be barred from serving as an officer or director of a public company. The Department of Justice can bring criminal charges, which can lead to fines and prison.

Can a Form 4 show illegal insider trading?

Not on its own. A Form 4 tells you that an insider traded, when, how many shares and at what price. It does not say what the insider knew or why they traded. A reported trade is not evidence of anything improper. Insiders sell to pay tax, to buy a home or to spread their savings, and they buy for many reasons too.

It also works the other way. Illegal trading is usually done by people who do not report, or through accounts in other names, so it does not show up in these filings at all.

Like everything on this site, this guide describes the rules and the public reports. It is not legal advice and it is not advice about any trade.

See the latest insider trades →